Books/Big Ideas

Big Ideas · 1961 – today

René Girard for Busy People

Why We Want What Others Want, Why Every Group Needs a Scapegoat, and How to Break Free

You have met the name. A podcast, a colleague, an article about Silicon Valley. René Girard is said to explain envy, online pile-ons and polarization, and almost nobody explains René Girard.

Readers who go looking tend to find two shelves. On one, a single idea of his, borrowed desire, has been turned into advice for founders; one reader found the tone “too exuberantly focused on start up success” and asked “where is role of advertising when it comes to mimetic desire?” On the other are the anthologies and Girard’s own books, which readers call “dense and hard to read straight through” and “heavy going.” Those who get through speak of “a fantastic key” and “a very useful tool.” They are less often told where the key stops turning.

This book gives the whole argument, in the order Girard reached it. First, that beyond hunger and thirst we learn what to want by watching what others want. Second, that people who want the same things become rivals, and that a group at war with itself can find peace by turning on one person, in all sincerity. Third, that the Bible tells that old story from the victim’s side, and that the modern world still lives on the reversal. Thirty-three short chapters start from situations you know (a toy on a nursery floor, two colleagues and one promotion, a school class, a message in a group channel) and only then name the idea. Each idea is then tried on a case that could prove it wrong.

Inside this book:
  • The triangle of desire, and why the colleague down the hall is a more dangerous model than a celebrity
  • How a quarrelling group settles on a culprit, from a Massachusetts village in 1692 to an airline passenger with her phone switched off
  • Advertising, status races, a billion-dollar investment, social feeds and two political parties, each tested against the theory
  • The critics in their own terms: the charge that the theory explains too much, the specialists, the feminist objection and the religious question
  • Two small habits for an ordinary week, and a reading guide to Girard’s own books

Written for readers who want the complete theory once, clearly, with the objections included: professionals who have heard the name at work, students who need a map before the primary texts, and book groups of any belief or none. No background in philosophy, Greek tragedy or theology is assumed, and every term is explained where it first appears.

Finish it and you will be able to say what Girard claimed and why each step needs the last, recognize a borrowed want of your own, and notice, a little sooner, when a room has settled on its culprit.

Inside the book

  1. Introduction: The Reply You Almost Sent
  2. Part One: A Reader of Novels
  3. 01A Frenchman in America
  4. 02What the Novelists Knew
  5. Part Two: Borrowed Desire
  6. 03The Toy on the Floor
  7. 04Models at a Distance
  8. 05The Colleague Down the Hall
  9. 06Why Rivals Turn into Twins
  10. 07The Third Person in the Couple
  11. 08Sold on Someone Else’s Wanting
  12. 09Equal, and Therefore Envious
  13. 10What the Laboratories Say
  14. Part Three: The Scapegoat
  15. 11When the Quarrel Spreads
  16. 12The Goat and the Word
  17. 13All Against One
  18. 14How a Victim Becomes a God
  19. 15Doing It Again on Purpose
  20. 16The Poet Who Believed the Rumor
  21. 17A Murder Without a Body
  22. Part Four: The Text That Took the Victim’s Side
Show the full contents (42 entries)
  1. 18Two Brothers, Twice
  2. 19Joseph and Oedipus
  3. 20The Trial Told from the Wrong Side
  4. 21Two Stonings
  5. 22The Age of the Victim
  6. Part Five: The Theory at Large
  7. 23The Student Who Bought Facebook
  8. 24A Machine for Showing What Others Want
  9. 25The Pile-On
  10. 26Two Parties, One Mirror
  11. 27The Coach, the Colleague, the Child
  12. 28Battling to the End
  13. Part Six: The Objections, and a Way Out
  14. 29A Key That Opens Every Door
  15. 30What the Specialists Said
  16. 31The Christian Question
  17. 32Choosing Whom to Copy
  18. 33The First to Walk Away
  19. Conclusion: Before You Press Send
  20. Which Girard to Read Next

Selected sources

A few of the documents and studies the book is built on.

  1. Girard, René (1961; English 1965). Deceit, Desire, and the Novel: Self and Other in Literary Structure. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press. (French: Mensonge romantique et vérité romanesque, Paris: Grasset.) Online ↗
  2. Girard, René (1972; English 1977). Violence and the Sacred. Translated by Patrick Gregory. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. (French: La Violence et le sacré, Paris: Grasset.) Online ↗
  3. Girard, René, with Jean-Michel Oughourlian and Guy Lefort (1978; English 1987). Things Hidden since the Foundation of the World. Translated by Stephen Bann and Michael Metteer. Stanford: Stanford University Press. (French: Des choses cachées depuis la fondation du monde, Paris: Grasset.) Online ↗
  4. Girard, René (1982; English 1986). The Scapegoat. Translated by Yvonne Freccero. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins University Press. (French: Le Bouc émissaire, Paris: Grasset.) Online ↗
  5. Girard, René (1999; English 2001). I See Satan Fall Like Lightning. Translated by James G. Williams. Maryknoll, NY: Orbis Books. (French: Je vois Satan tomber comme l’éclair, Paris: Grasset.) Online ↗
  6. Girard, René, with Benoît Chantre (2007; English 2009/2010). Battling to the End: Conversations with Benoît Chantre. Translated by Mary Baker. East Lansing: Michigan State University Press. (French: Achever Clausewitz, Paris: Carnets Nord.) Online ↗
  7. Hamerton-Kelly, Robert G., ed. (1987). Violent Origins: Walter Burkert, René Girard, and Jonathan Z. Smith on Ritual Killing and Cultural Formation. Stanford: Stanford University Press. Online ↗
  8. Thiel, Peter, with Blake Masters (2014). Zero to One: Notes on Startups, or How to Build the Future. New York: Crown Business. Online ↗